EDARA
The EDARA project evaluated alcohol treatment centres including the implications for service delivery, patient benefit and harm reduction.
Introduction
Drunkenness is a common night-time problem in the UK, and intoxicated individuals are at risk of choking, injury, unconsciousness and death. Traditionally, the very drunk were either detained by police or sent to Emergency Departments (ED). However, recent police guidance restricts custody for the drunk, leading to increased pressure on EDs. This surge in demand causes delays in ambulance handovers, police duties, and patient care. Additionally, the disruptive behaviour of intoxicated individuals can negatively impact the ED environment, affecting other patients and staff.
Alcohol Intoxication Management Services ((AIMS) – also known as Alcohol Treatment Centres, Alcohol Recovery Centres, Alcohol Welfare Centres and, in the media, 'Drunk Tanks' – are designed to receive, treat and monitor intoxicated patients who would normally attend Emergency Departments and to lessen the burden that alcohol-misuse, an avoidable healthcare cost, places on unscheduled care.
They are usually located close to areas characterised by excessive intoxication and are open at times when levels of intoxication peak (e.g. Friday and Saturday evenings). AIMS therefore offer the potential to mitigate some of the pressures on ED at times when it is experiencing a sustained increase in demand.
Project aims
The EDARA project aims to estimate the effectiveness, cost-effectiveness, efficiency and acceptability of AIMS in managing alcohol-related ED attendances. It is organised into three Work Streams (WS):
WS1 will use ethnographic studies; interviews with stakeholders, policy makers and practitioners;
interviews with patients attending AIMS and surveys of ED and AIMS users. It focuses on four
research questions:
- What is the impact of AIMS on the work practices and professional identities of frontline staff in managing the intoxicated and other related work activities?
- What are the micro-, meso- and macro-levels factors that contribute to AIMS development and implementation, what are the key ingredients required for successful implementation and what barriers to implementation exist across partnerships?
- To what extent is treatment in AIMS acceptable to users?
- To what extent does implementation of an AIMS affect users' views on treatment in EDs?
In WS2 routine data will be analysed to quantify the effect of AIMS in respect of key performance indicators. WS2 addresses the research question 'to what extent does AIMS implementation affect key performance indicators in ambulance and health services?'.
WS3 addresses the question 'what are the costs of setting up and running an AIMS and what cost savings may be realised elsewhere?'. WS3 works alongside WS2 and in addition collates data required for cost-efficiency analyses. If AIMS are found to be effective, in respect of key performance indicators, this WS will feed forward into a separate project that models the likely effect of a national rollout.
Key project information
This study is funded by the NIHR Public Health Research programme (Award ID 14/04/25). The views expressed are those of the author(s) and not necessarily those of the NIHR or the Department of Health and Social Care.
Dates
January 2016 – June 2018
Funding
£714,693.81
Principal investigator
Professor Simon Moore
Institutions involved
Cardiff University
University of Sheffield
University of Newcastle, Australia
Key contact
Papers
Moore SC, Allen D, Amos Y, Blake J, Brennan A, Buykx P, et al. (2020) Evaluating alcohol intoxication management services: the EDARA mixed-methods study Health and Social Care Delivery Research DOI: https://doi.org/10.3310/hsdr08240
Irving A, Goodacre S, Blake J, Allen D, Moore SC (2018) Managing alcohol-related attendances in emergency care: can diversion to bespoke services lessen the burden? Emergency Medicine Journal DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/emermed-2016-206451
You might also be interested in…
New modelling of alcohol harms in Scotland
The Sheffield Alcohol Research Group has today (20 September 2023) published a major new report on the impact of alcohol pricing policies, alcohol consumption and harm in Scotland.
Gambling
The Sheffield Addictions Research Group is actively engaged in emerging areas of gambling research, seeking to understand and address the complex issues surrounding addiction and public health.
Local alcohol treatment and recovery service commissioning practices and their perceived outcomes for service provision: An in-depth exploration
This project examined the experience of alcohol service commissioning processes at a local authority level in five diverse localities.