Appraising the effect of implementing local minimum unit pricing on alcohol consumption and health in the North West of England
This project aimed to provide evidence about what would happen if minimum unit pricing was introduced by local authorities in North West England.
Introduction
Each year harms from alcohol cost the NHS £3.5 billion and wider society £21 billion. The UK Alcohol Strategy 2012 included a plan to introduce a policy called 'minimum unit pricing' (MUP).
Under MUP, the price at which alcohol can be sold is linked to the amount of pure alcohol (e.g. under a MUP of 50p per alcohol unit, a bottle of wine containing 10 units could not be sold for less than £5).
Although research shows this policy would probably reduce the amount of alcohol drunk and the number of hospital admissions and deaths caused by alcohol, by 2014 the government decided not to introduce MUP.
Local authorities (LAs) are responsible for responding to alcohol harms in their communities. The North West (NW) region of England has a higher than average level of alcohol harms. As MUP was not introduced for England as a whole, there is a high level interest in the North West in introducing MUP locally.
Expert legal advice says that one possible way to introduce MUP is for local authorities to use a law called the Sustainable Communities Act to ask the UK government to allow them to set a local MUP. To do this, local authorities need to:
- Demonstrate local support for MUP
- Provide local evidence that MUP would be beneficial for the health of people in the North West
Aims
This project aimed to address the second point above by providing evidence about what would happen if MUP was introduced by local authorities in the North West. Specifically, what would happen to the price of different types of alcohol, what effect these price changes would have on how much alcohol people drink and on the number of hospital admissions and deaths caused by alcohol, as well as changes to quality of life and NHS costs.
Method
To test what would happen to the amount of alcohol drunk if MUP were introduced locally, we took several steps:
- We combined survey and market research data (bought through this research grant) to work out how much alcohol of different types is currently bought and at what price.
- We used national survey data to estimate how much people currently drink in each local authority area.
- Using evidence from previous research on how people respond to price changes, we worked out how the amount of alcohol bought and consumed would change if there was a MUP. We worked this out for nine different levels of MUP (30p, 35, 40, 45, 50, 55, 60, 65, 70p).
After working out what change there would be in the amount of alcohol drunk, we were able to estimate what difference this would make to harms. We:
- Used hospital information about the number of patients with conditions caused by alcohol to work out how many fewer cases there would be.
- Used death records on the number of people dying of alcohol-related causes to work out how many fewer deaths there would be.
- Converted these estimates to quality-adjusted life-years (QALY) which is a measure of quality and quantity of life gained from introducing a particular health policy.
- Estimated what changes would occur under MUP for 20 years for different population groups (e.g. more or less wealthy, and for light, moderate and heavy drinkers) for each local authority in the North West. We also undertook comparison with eight other regions.
Impact
Our work provided evidence about the likely scale of impact of MUP in the North West region. The local authorities, with whom we engaged in developing the bid, planned to use this to make a submission under the Sustainable Communities Act.
Key project information
This study was funded by the NIHR Public Health Research programme (Award ID: 15/129/19). The views expressed are those of the author(s) and not necessarily those of the NIHR or the Department of Health and Social Care.
Dates
April 2017 – September 2018
Funding
£281,614.42
Chief investigator
Professor Alan Brennan
Institutions involved
University of Sheffield
Key contact
Research team
Professor Alan Brennan
Dr Duncan Gillespie
Dr Penny Buykx
Dr Robert Pryce
Colin Angus
Professor John Holmes
Professor Petra Meier
Papers
Brennan A, Angus C, Pryce R, Buykx P, Henney M, Gillespie D, Holmes J, Meier PS (2022) Effectiveness of subnational implementation of minimum unit price for alcohol: policy appraisal modelling for local authorities in England Addiction DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/add.16084
Pryce R, Angus C, Holmes J, Gillespie D, Buykx P, Meier P, Hickman M, de Vochy F, Brennan A (2020) Reweighting national survey data for small area behaviour estimates: modelling alcohol consumption in Local Authorities in England Population Health Metrics DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s12963-019-0201-0
Gavens L, Holmes J, Buykx P, de Vocht F, Egan M, Grace D, Lock K, Mooney JD, Brennan A (2019) Processes of local alcohol policy-making in England: Does the theory of policy transfer provide useful insights into public health decision-making Health & Place DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.healthplace.2017.05.016
Brennan A, Angus C, Pryce R, Buykx P, Henney M, Gillespie D, Holmes J, Meier PS (2019) Potential effects of minimum unit pricing at local authority level on alcohol-attributed harms in North West and North East England: a modelling study Public Health Research DOI: https://doi.org/10.3310/phr09040
You might also be interested in…
Minimum unit pricing
The Sheffield Addictions Research Group has been highly influential in the introduction of minimum unit pricing (MUP) for alcohol in Scotland, Wales and the Republic of Ireland. Here we answer some common questions about minimum unit pricing.
New modelling of alcohol harms in Scotland
The Sheffield Alcohol Research Group has today (20 September 2023) published a major new report on the impact of alcohol pricing policies, alcohol consumption and harm in Scotland.
Evaluating the impact of minimum unit pricing in Scotland on harmful drinkers
This project evaluated the impact of Scotland's minimum unit pricing (MUP) policy on people drinking at harmful levels, including those with alcohol dependence.